We finished off this scenario over three more evening sessions of three hours each - so about 20 hours gaming in total! Only a wargamer would think this was a good thing. If you haven't seen Part 1 of the report it can be found here, but to briefly recap...
A devastating opening bombardment broke Low's KGL brigade, badly damaged Langwerth's and destroyed Rattberg's battery. Ruffin's division then led off the attack with an assault on the left flank of the British lines, trying to seize the Cerro de Medellin, supported by Beaumont's cavalry which looped around to attack the rear of the lightly held British left.
In a surprise move, Perrin shifted Solignac over to the French right to support Ruffin, but in an order mix up Ruffin went straight up the Medellin rather than following Beaumont in a more looping movement. This created a traffic jam and as a result Solignac came up the centre of the Medellin against Tilson's brigade.
On the French left Lapisse held back Laplanne's brigade as Latour-Maubourg's Dragoon division clashed with Fane's British cavalry division, now in the attack. That division was weakened by the dispatch of Anson who was hustled off to the British left to counter Beaumont's move to that flank.
The scenario map again... |
The first session ended with the British hard-pressed by the French left and centre and Beaumont's cavalry threatening to sweep in behind the British lines, which had essentially formed a massive square on the top of the Medellin!
So, picking up where I left off in the last report...
1/29th's volley and charge shattered by a volley in line from the French
Stewart’s 1/29th (facing Meunier and Barrois on French right), trying to reagin the initiative, is driven off with a devastating volley and the brigade breaks.
Anson's horse routs the lead squadrons of Beaumont's light cavalry brigade
But fortunately Anson brigade has arrived just in time to shore up the British left. The 23rd LD charge and break the 5me Regt. de Chas. a Cheval and rout the lead squadrons of the 2me Hussards as well. Beaumont's brigade breaks but the final exchange routs the exhausted 23rd as well. However Beaumont manages to rally his remaining horse in time to meet the follow up charge of the 1st KGL Light Dragoons.
Beaumont in full retreat
However the 1st KGL LD crush Beaumont's last unit, sending them routing. As a result Beaumont's cannon, supporting the attack on that flank, was also forced to limber up and retreat, relieving a bit of the pressure.
Routing 23rd LD
Anson's victory does not come without cost, as the 23rd LD's rout as well.
Cavalry trade off on British right
A slug fest develops on the other side. The lead French dragoon brigade is broken, fails to rally, but then the subsequent wave of French horse destroys the exhausted lead Guard squadron. Eliott's battery, blocked by a swirl of cavalry, prepares to limber up and move to higher ground.
But waves of dragoons continue to wash forward to meet British cavalry attack
With reserves either side the fight goes on.
Solignac's columns charge Tilson's 2/48th
In the centre Tilson’s 2/48th takes the brunt of Solignac's attack, breaking Solignac’s skirmish battalion, routing a second, before routing two more of Solignac’s line battalions sent in to attack in column. They finished with destroying a limbered French battery which had thought it was moving up behind the front lines. So they had a very good opening period.
Ruffin's right goes into square
With Anson's horse now threatening and the French horse artillery guns moving off, the 2/9th Legere form square, with the farm anchoring the other end of the 3/96me's line. With his flank now protected Ruffin, having paused for a moment to regroup, sends his troops back into the brawl, especially in light of the mauling Solignac has just endured at the hands of the British 2/48th.
Overview British left
On the left Stewart's 1/29th and Battalion of Detachments, still in the front, begins to withdraw as Langwerth's 1st and 2nd KGL (behind, centre) arrive to take over their positions. Top right Tilson's brigade still holds firm, although worn down by the French attacks.
4th Dragoons tangle with the next line of French
The British heavies continue to tangle with the French Dragoons, routing the second wave of Latour-Maubourg's division as Stapleton Cotton dispatches his Light Dragoons (top left) to threaten Laplanne's flank. Laplanne throws a couple of his battalions into square to counter this threat.
2/48th stormed a second time!
Another wave of French infantry columns pour up against the British centre, this time driving back the weary 2/48th on to their supports.
2/48th destroyed
For once French columns carry the day, destroying the 2/48th but then pausing to lick their wounds rather than carrying on into the fresh 3rd Buffs standing in support on the ridge. But this attack is enough to break Tilson's brigade, which now joins Low's and Stewart's in withdrawing as the British throw in the last of their reserves, Donkin's 87th and 88th, to plug the gap in the centre.
Perrin in the thick of it
On the banks of the Portina Perrin and his headquarters are in the thick of it directing the main attack as seemingly endless columns of French march on the Cerro de Medellin.
1/29th driven back
In a second successful charge in columns of the day, Ruffin's troops crash into the 1/29th, already retreating from the field, pushing them back into Langwerth as he advances to the position.
Lapisse's attack rolled up!
Buoyed by successes on the French right and centre, Lapisse desperately tries to break Hayse' battery of 6 pdrs., which has been holding up the advance of Laplanne's brigade along with a few of Donkin's light troops on the British right centre. A first head on charge is routed by canister but as his troops form up for a second attempt disaster strikes.
Stapleton Cotton, on the flank and waiting for such an opportunity, charges his 16th LD's forward in column of squadrons. Laplanne's flanking voltigeur battalion hastily tries to form square but are dashed aside. In the ensuing chaos the Light Dragoons slam into the flank of the battalion preparing to attack the battery, break a third column also advancing up the Medellin and finally smash into a fourth before coming to a halt. In the blink of an eye four battalions are destroyed and Laplanne's fresh brigade is in danger of collapsing.
Overview
With both sides barely hanging on, things have certainly improved for the British! Lower right the opposing cavalries pause in their on-going clashes to regroup. Above them Laplanne will rally next turn, but with only half of his original force, and all driven back over the Porrtina as a result of the 16th LD's crushing rout of his lead forces.
On the Cerro de Medellin top left the British look stronger than they are with three brigades now in full retreat, but Donkin and Langwerth arriving just in time to stem the tide.
Far top left Anson's 1st KGL Hussars hover, threatening the French right.
Barrois' 96me charges Langwerth's 1st KGL
Once again columns are sent against line, and, despite a crushing volley and charge from the KGL, the columns triumph. The 1st KGL is sent reeling backwards and, still weakened from the initial French barrage, Langwerth's brigade is broken! But the two 96me battalions are also nearly spent and need to pause to regroup.
Payne sends Cotton's LD's to the front
With Fane's heavies close to breaking after dispatching two of the French Dragoon brigades, Payne takes advantage of the French regrouping their surviving dragoons to pull the heavies back, moving Cotton's 14th and 16th LD's into the front line.
French batteries not finding their targets
As the remnants of Laplanne's brigade stumble back over the Portina the French guns deliver some desultory fire, unsuccessfully trying to silence Heyse's battery in the centre.
Anson's 1st KGL Hussars sweep down on French skirmishers
On the French right Barrois' skirmish battalions venture too far from their supports as the waiting KGL Hussars sweep down off the Medellin.
Another trail of destruction on the French right
History repeats itself on the French right as the first skirmish battalion fails to form emergency square and the Hussars sweep the fleeing voltigeurs ahead of them, rolling up a second ad hoc skirmish battalion and the 2/96me before ending the charge catching the 1/96me in column, still recovering from breaking Langwerth. Barrois' brigade is broken!
Donkin's 87th POW charges down the Medellin
In the final act, the 87th POW Own Irish, faced with Solignac's centre battalions having been forced into closed columns by the 16th LD's charge, seize the moment to volley and charge, breaking one battalion and crashing into a second. However Solignac was already broken and in withdrawal over the Portina.
Game end
The French commander, Alan, threw in the towel at this point at the end of Turn 10. We rolled to see the fate of Solignac and Barrois, and although Barrois rallied, he only had one remaininng battalion and that about to be destroyed by the 1st KGL Hussars. That loss would put the French over the fatigue hit threshold needed to continue fighting.
But the British were close to breaking as well. Fortunately Langwerth rallied, but if he had failed and Anson's horse had suffered two more hits and failed to rally, the British would have been pushed over the edge as well! The loss of the heavies, also possible if they had been charged a final time, would also have pushed the British well over the threshold.
So a battlefield recap.
Bottom right the last brigade of the Dragoon Division, now under command of a nameless underling after the loss of Latour-Maubourg, face off against the still fresh light dragoons of Stapleton Cotton as they prepare to charge the French left.
Above Laplanne's surviving battalions, now regrouped have all retreated back over the Portina and can do little in the face of the British horse.
Above those, centre, the 87th have swept down the Medellin and engaged Solignac's brigade, now in full retreat, while upper right Barrois is destroyed by the KGL Hussars, leaving only Meunier, with a single fatigue hit, still in play!
But on the left on the Cerro de Medellin the British are not in much better shape, with three brigades of infantry in full withdrawal and Langwerth only hanging on by his toenails after being drummed back by Barrois.
If you are still reading this, I hope you enjoyed the report. It was a gruelling 20 hours or more of playing time, but well worth every moment and the battle ebbed and flowed - a lot of fun, and great to have all those toys finally on the table. Thanks, JJ, for yet another extremely enjoyable scenario, and thanks Alan, Phong and Brian for showing up at the table. On to the Battle for the Redoubt, Talavera Part 4.
What a fantastic game Bill, your narrative had me on the edge of my seat! A very hard fought win for the British, the French certainly seemed in the ascendancy for most of the game. Unusually, it seemed to be the British cavalry who saved the day!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Ross, for taking the time to read the report through - I'm glad you enjoyed it. it really was a nail biter, with both sides expecting not to last another round intact. I think the British got very lucky with their horse!
DeleteA big thank you for the pictures and surely the time taken to write and post the report. What a game!
ReplyDeleteCPN
Absolutely my pleasure. I enjoy going through my photos, recreating the game and writing the reports - definitely value-added to the game itself
DeleteThat looks like it was some game. Beautifully presented and written up.
ReplyDeleteDid you find that the rules still worked well in such a big game?
Yes, Morty, I thought the rules held up very well. The French resented Ruffin having to attack straight up the Medellin (scenario opening orders) when they wanted to execute more of a flank attack, but I felt that could have been resolved with new orders (which we use) early on. They were already re-jigging the scenario to their liking, which is fine, but that gave the French an even greater advantage in a game which was already a what-if, allowing Lapisse to attack whereas he didn't historically.
DeleteI guess for some people the amount of time it took to finish would be a barrier - a slimmed down ruleset would have concluded things much more quickly and as I was the one carrying most of the rules in my head, it was a bit exhausting playing and rule-lawyering. But I like the intricacies of OTH. I think this size of battle pretty well pushes OTH to the limit in terms of playability, if not for any other reason than the table gets too large to reach to the middle, in 1/72, anyway!
That’s very interesting. I guess you would have lost something of the character of your game if you had switched to a higher level of command style rules. It must be very satisfying to put so much time and effort into the prep and playing and see it through. I also guess - from your table size - that you and your friends must be naturally blessed with long arms!
ReplyDeleteTheir arms are getting longer! I'm best-suited to the table size so sometimes they point, I move...
DeleteBack to Crete now eh...?
ReplyDeleteNorth Africa, probably, but yes.
DeleteHi Bill,
ReplyDeleteWow, what a game!
Talavera has the potential to produce this kin of battle, given that the French troops are of such a high quality and probably one of the most powerful French armies Wellesley faced in his career, composed as it was of the veterans of Jena, Austerlitz and Eylau and who were very used to winning.
Likewise the British troops are good but not as experienced and effective as they would become in the 1812 Salamanca campaign and beyond and so these two armies can really go toe to toe with each other and produce a game like this with the outcome still in doubt right to the bitter end.
Great game, well done
JJ
Thanks again for writing a great scenario, JJ. I'm glad you enjoyed it. Yes, it was quite the surprise outcome - the defeat of Beaumont by Anson was pivotal but I still doubt that the British would have prevailed without the French flanks opening themselves to the cavalry attacks. So the British did get lucky!
Delete